Aug21
Instant Replay in Baseball: A Great Idea, But It Can Wait
By Sean Connolly
15 years ago. That’s when the idea of instant replay was introduced to the fools running major league baseball. When it was introduced teams voted 27-1 against the idea of instant replay. It continued to be shut down by teams like that until 1998 when the Diamondbacks and Rays were brought to the league in which the vote went from 27 to 29-1.Now, half way through the 2008 season, MLB has decided to implement instant replay despite not having it completely figured out. Seems to me that if we’ve waited all this time, we can wait another half season until everything is sorted out.
The talk of bringing instant replay began this season in May when, in a two week span, several home run calls were missed by umpires. Unfortunately for these umpires and the MLB, a few of these games were nationally televised bringing more light to the situation. Not only that but one of the more controversial non-homeruns was hit by a man who may someday break Barry Bonds’ record of all-time homeruns, Alex Rodriguez. All of these missed calls were seen nation wide on ESPN’s instant replay showing the umpire’s blunders. Fans, writers, and anyone in the sports community were at Bud Selig’s door with pitchforks and torches asking for instant replay. Like the coward he is, Selig gave in.
Granted instant replay is the correct choice, believe me I’ve wanted it for years now, but in the middle of the season? C’mon. The best part about it is that everyone is so divided on the whole thing in baseball. The umpires don’t want it, all of a sudden half the MLB teams want it, half don’t (a vote recently said it was 15 in favor, 15 against), and players are begging for it. So, what does Selig do. Without mulling it over with the umpires, players, and owners after the season had completed, he decided that instant replay would be a part of Major League Baseball today. Out of nowhere!!
How can half the season be played under different rules? That’s so insane to me. A hit that was a homerun in May wasn’t, but a hit that’s a homerun in say September or October all of a sudden is. That’s not how professional sports work. When the NFL realized that they needed instant replay, they didn’t implement it in the middle of the season. They tested it out in Europe, discussed their plans thouroughly making sure refs, players, and owners agreed on what was happening and then brought forth the plan at the start of the season.
I want instant replay so badly it’s not even funny. But I refuse to give up my sport ethics for a rule that doesn’t even seem like it’s been figured out. The MLB is saying that instant replay will only be used for homerun calls. There is going to be so much confusion as to whether or not they can use instant replay or not on several types of calls, such as a trapped ball scenario. This will only open up a door of problems for the umpires that they didn’t have to deal with earlier in this season.
The solution is simple people. Use instant replay on a majority of calls, but next year. Train the umpires properly and make sure that all rules are sorted out, and that both managers and umpires know what can or cannot be challenged by instant replay. We’ve waited 15 years for this, don’t you want that wait to be worth something?
No Comments »A-Rod, AL East, Alex Rodriguez, Alex Rodriguez Blown HR Call MLB Instant Replay, American League, Barry Bonds, Baseball, Bud Selig, Bud Selig Commisioner, Bud Selig Instant Replay, Devil Rays, Hitting, Instant Replay, MLB, MLB Instant Replay, MLB Instant Replay Rules, MLB Replay, MLB Rules, MLB Season 08, MLB Season 08 Instant Replay, MLB Umpires Instant Replay, MLB umpires, Major League Baseball, Mlb Instant Replay debate, National League East, New York Mets, New York Yankees, Pitching, Playoffs, Sean Connolly, Sean Connolly Baseball, Sean Connolly Sports, Sean Connolly Sports Writer, Uncategorized, World Series, Yankee Stadium










